Ok, I'm going to finally get in here and post my views on this movie that changed my
life…though from my profile, one might assume that I was ripe for it. LOL! But I've
been quiet about it for long enough. It's definitely time I said my piece (or pieces) about
this incredible film and cultural milestone.
***
Thank you very much to everyone who opened themselves up to a firestorm in order
to do a wonderful, heart-changing thing; some who challenged themselves and their
own pain by going to see this film, some who challenged upbringing or the catcalls
and judgment of friends and family to do the same; and those who challenged
themselves all the more by taking the initiative to write and or speak honestly and
openly about how this movie/story affected you. It is always difficult and a risk to
share a difficult and eye-opening personal experience; but doing so challenges us all;
and it's the folks that dare to do these things that will change the world for the
better; this simple willingness to inspect the true root of our beliefs, separate out
what we've been taught from what we find truly affecting and related to our own
experience. For all of you out there with this bravery, know; it is self-challenging and
the sharing of experiences like these that will change and better the world and our
perceptions of Faith, one heart at a time as we learn and grow...or rather, allow
ourselves to hear these messages. I'm glad this movie is one that will do that with
some, should they allow themselves to approach the message long enough to let it
work whatever change in their hearts that they need on their journey. I cannot judge
their journey, for I am on my own, and each of us has experiences that make no
sense to anyone but ourselves; for we are the only ones that see the world through
our eyes. Therefore we cannot condemn the ways others live based on their
experiences; we have not the point of view to do so. Only God/Spirit can see the
world as we ALL do...and if that is the only omniscience, then none of us can judge.
Love thy neighbor, and leave the Judging to God, I say...and all I can think is that
too many people must not love themselves, if they cannot love others as they
*should* love themselves. And that makes me sad. But every day also gives me
reason to hope.
.
Movies like this one (read, movies that speak of real human emotion and the real
daily tragedies of human experience; and movies that let us FEEL these emotions,
tragedies, and experiences rather than telling us what to feel in words) are rare in
this market of stupid comedies and explosions...rare especially in broader 'market
cinema'. But when they do get out there, break out of the 'indie movie' circuit and
become more readily accessible, if they can change even one person's life, then my
hopes for the world are affirmed. Many condemn these movies as a knee-jerk,
without even knowing wherefrom they speak...they 'KNOW' the movie is 'evil'
because they 'KNOW' it...not because they challenged themselves in any way to
actually SEE it first. Indeed, I doubt many of these folks who are so vehemently
against the so-called 'gay agenda' went to see "Brokeback" or "Transamerica", or
they might realize that the only agenda most of us have is to be loved, respected,
and treated as human beings.
.
Granted, many cities didn't show these movies, meaning that folks who WANTED to
see them in some areas would have had to drive or fly to another city to do so
proving once and for all that our 'elected' officials think of us as children to be
'protected' from ourselves rather than simply giving us the choice to watch
something or not, but that is a whole other rant. But as I've said above, it is my
belief that no one should have an opinion on something they haven't seen/
experienced for themselves, or at least tried to put themselves in those shoes
for a moment or two. Experiences cannot be judged, because no one but the
experiencer has any idea what the heck they're talking about; and if anything has
actually been experienced by someone, then it is as valid as any other experience. I
cannot judge the validity of the effect that any experience has had on another
person's life; I can only judge my own...but it is the fact that, upon discussion, so
many people had such a similar experience with this film that makes me feel that we
really all have a great deal more in common than we might believe; as much as the
experience might have touched us for different reasons...for we are all different.
Thank God.
.
Speaking of wonderful variety, I too would have liked to see more variety in the
awards. This has been a great year for movies, with many making very important
points (which in my world means moviemaking at its best; using the power of the
screen to reach out and make people THINK...even if some would prefer to spend
their money on trashy, big-budget remakes that don't strain their faculties or
comfort zones at all). "Munich" and "Good Night and Good Luck" and perhaps
"Crash" certainly deserve more awards. But all in all it's been a very intelligent movie
year; and a year with a whole BUNCH of standouts makes it hard to get a good
spread on the awards.
.
Still, part of me is also elated. Who would have thought a film like "Brokeback"
would have made it to eight nominations in any show in the US? (Or that
"Transamerica" would win anything in this country?!) The fact that they can even be
shown in mainstream theaters in this country--whatever the limitations put on
circulation--rather than being restricted to the 'arthouse' circuit as they once would
have been shows how far we've come. And when I saw "Brokeback", three times
thus far in the week since it's gotten enough buzz to actually leave the 'safe' cities
for the second tier, there were a lot of straight men wearing western attire there
with their wives...and people came out thoughtful and moved. And that right there is
a testament to how we're FINALLY, if slowly, growing as a society. It's the first thing
in a long time that's given me hope that the USA might actually get back to what
was once great about it, and maybe even live up to its great potential after all...as a
country where, one hopes, someday everyone will be safe and free to live and love
without needing to harm anyone else to *feel* safe...instead of just talking about it.
.
I have now seen this movie three times, and wish I could see it more; for each time,
I have found something different; deeper, more heart-wrenching...and in the end,
salving. I have seldom seen a movie whose cinematography, writing, music, casting,
editing, direction, production, setting, and overall feel were so in tune. "Dances With
Wolves" springs to mind. Day-Lewis and Stowe's "Last of the Mohicans". And yes, oh
yes, although this one came at a time when the movie could not be as brave as
"Brokeback" with its adaptation, "Fried Green Tomatoes", beside which "Brokeback"
has its rightful place reserved on my shelf, as the novella stands beside "Fried Green
Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe" on my shelf of literary masterpieces. Because in
the end it's not about the make-up for the necessary but difficult 'aging', not about
why Gyllenhall is called a 'supporter', why Hathaway didn't get recognized as much
as Williams...but about the EXPERIENCE...and how it changed every one of us who
saw it. I cannot wait for the deleted scenes sure to be on the DVD (as evidenced by
dialogue and scenes not seen in the theatrical release but shown or heard in the
trailers), hoping that with more Jack and Ennis, I might get just one more tiny clue
more as to WHY...and maybe even...'someday'.
.
For this reason, I went to find the novella, and read it in minutes, starving for
meaning; driven by the pain...and the reluctant beauty. For this reason I went back
and back again; and as many have said, the first time, the ending shattered me, the
few moments of dialogue staggered me ("And then you tell me you'll kill me for
needin' something I hardly never git! I wish I knew how to quit you!" "Then why
don't you? You're the reason I am the way I am! I have nothin', I am nothin'..." and
the terrible catharsis of "You aren't nothing. I love you," still unspoken...and the
image of what has been lost because in that time and place, it simply could not be
had. The second time, the music stepped out as a star, where in the first viewing, it
was so much a part of the experience that I didn't hear it so much as *felt* it. Now
every time I hear that music, those few beautifully spare, painful, poignant chords of
lonely guitar, I see Ennis holding the shirts, looking at the postcard, and I cry as I
haven't cried in or at a movie since I forced myself to stop crying at anything, at age
six, for similar reasons to Ennis's, though in a much different situation. And in the
last time, while still shattered, I even managed to find a kind of peace with the
finality of the ending; and the faint breath of hope, like air, that breaks into the
terrible self-imposed claustrophobia of the final image of Ennis Del Mar; still with his
love and pain in the literal closet...but now able to cry, and promise Jack what he
could not in life. "I know better now; we would have lost anyway. But at least we
wouldn't have lost the years, too; and what might have been before this end."
.
A movie with a message that, like the protestations of love that so many feel are
necessary to *portray* love, connection, loss...did not need narration to worm its
way into the hearts of everyone watching, gay, straight, or self-challenging; a
message and moment and music that haunts long after the movie ends, and
demands another viewing just to try to get it right in one's head. "WHY did it have to
be this way?" Because it WAS. And in some places, sadly...it still is.
.
I waited for the Oscars tonight to see if true Artistry and pure experience would win
out over market value. I guess we're not quite there yet, because the battle became
about the hype, though this movie that is not really *about* being gay, and that
finally pokes holes in a stereotype (the Western Man, the Cowboy, not the gay man
or the ex-gay) that badly needed some air let in to reality. Monolithic status and
unrealistic pedestals do no one any good, as no one who is human can live up to
such standards, which have nothing to do with reality and the real human condition.
I feel justified in saying these things having been raised in a place much like 'Signal
Wyoming'; Crouch Idaho, home of a rodeo ground and only 600 cowboys, where the
only way out was bullriding or logging for Boise Cascade, and the teen pregnancy
rate was the highest in the US, and grinding poverty was the norm, and lack of
education celebrated as a cultural plaudit. These things became part of my bones;
the bleakness of that life, all the things I was so desperate to escape. Now it is gone,
and in its place are a new generation of people who have never worked so hard for
so little in their lives, moved to 'God's Country' to 'go country', and think that putting
on the hat and boots and listening to Garth Brooks makes them 'cowboys' who have
a right and the authority to comment on the portrayal of a lifestyle they really know
nothing about.
.
No true cowboy or ranch hand that I ever met, be it sheep or cattle or horses, would
walk into any building without taking their hats off. They didn't *talk* about being
cowboys, try to prove it. They simply were. Them I respect, despite my reservations
about the lifestyle. I do not respect the grand mass of folks who talk about this
movie as if they know what they are talking about, for most of them didn't even
bother to watch it...and most of them have never met a TRUE cowboy. If they did,
they'd learn something about shooting off at the mouth when you don't know nothin'
about the life. And I've seen quite a few of this sort of old school cowboy at this
movie; and when they left they were all talking with their wives, or crying. And if a
real cowboy can cry for a true human drama, then who are we to challenge that? To
me if even one person has had a new experience, opened themselves and been
touched, then Oscars or not, "Brokeback" has already won.
.
I've gotten a bit far afield here, but I'll come back to the beginning long enough to
thank everyone in here once more for their willingness to stick it out there...both to
allow the film to work in you in whatever way it was meant to in your personal
journey and experience, and for your willingness to share that experience with
others so that we all might be enriched in our own experiences. With discussion
comes learning; and IMO, that's what we're here for...to learn from each other and
in that way find greater Understanding and Love.
.
I'll close with the following quote:
"Some people might be amazed to discover that other people can be spiritually-
minded, and yet not use their spiritual vocabulary."
.
This quote helps me to try to live the tolerance that I request from others. Since our
spiritual vocabulary, as with any of our vocabularies, comes from our worldly
experience (of spirituality, the world, life, etc), and each experience is different,
therefore the vocabularies we use to describe those experiences to each other
*must* in fact be different. And as language is worldly, it is inherently inaccurate for
such experiences...but as it is the only tool we have to share such things, we must
use that gift from God and discuss, Discuss, DISCUSS!!!
.
May love and wonder work within us ALL.
Tags: activism, gay, movies, news, sexuality
Currently Living In...: Olympia, WA
Fuzzy or Emo?:
discontent
Brought To You By:: "Trouble", by the Indigo Girls!